This is for every teacher who refuses to be blamed for the failure of our society to erase poverty and inequality, and refuses to accept assessments, tests and evaluations imposed by those who have contempt for real teaching and learning.
Reading is great, joining is better - please sign in. For BATs, by BATs, we do not sell data!
BAT Store
Click image for link
We have now gotten a US Made and Union shop to sell us BAT shirts in all designs at a low cost.
Bumper stickers are coming soon and we hope to add more shirt types (tank, polo) if there is interest in the t-shirts!
We don't expect everyone who goes to university to get a PhD. How can we expect all students to graduate high school with a diploma if they don't meet a set of criteria?
It seems to be part of the self-esteem 'everybody gets a trophy' mentality. The reality is, some people achieve more than others.
Last Edit: Sept 1, 2013 21:59:14 GMT -5 by kumumele
"From Mark Naison - The simplest argument against the Common Core Standards- they cost school districts large amounts of money to implement; and put those funds in the hands of test companies and consultants. Whatever its original intentions, it has morphed into a huge fund transfer from the public to the private sphere
This can probably only be handled by litigation. We can protest, wear shirts, refuse to take tests, but nothing's gonna happen. Sorry for being the canary in the cave.
Elly, if we are noisy and irritating long enough, someone is bound to listen to us. Sufficient numbers make for a revolution, regardless of who's in power.
Sorry. That didn't work for gun control, and it probably won't work here. Sorry to be such a pessimist, but this is a VERY LARGE issue that can't be la-dee-dah'ed.
We don't expect everyone who goes to university to get a PhD. How can we expect all students to graduate high school with a diploma if they don't meet a set of criteria?
It seems to be part of the self-esteem 'everybody gets a trophy' mentality. The reality is, some people achieve more than others.
I don't expect all of my students to 'earn' a diploma, but I also believe that some of them COULD earn a diploma if given more time and more support .. and if they were tested on material when they were READY to be tested on it.
Elem spec ed, 29th year (also gen ed, g/t, college experience) Indiana & Texas
We don't expect everyone who goes to university to get a PhD. How can we expect all students to graduate high school with a diploma if they don't meet a set of criteria?
It seems to be part of the self-esteem 'everybody gets a trophy' mentality. The reality is, some people achieve more than others.
I don't expect all of my students to 'earn' a diploma, but I also believe that some of them COULD earn a diploma if given more time and more support .. and if they were tested on material when they were READY to be tested on it.
You don't think that giving a kid until they're 22 is sufficient time to earn a diploma?
Last Edit: Sept 2, 2013 11:41:25 GMT -5 by kumumele
Post by ladywclass on Sept 2, 2013 11:44:54 GMT -5
I think it is if we don't make them take a test every year for about 10 of those that they 'fail'.
I'm a pretty intelligent person, but if I had to take a calculus test in 5th grade, I would have failed because I didn't have the skills YET to take that test. If we constantly test a kid before they have learned the concepts, then they build up a history of failure which makes it even harder to approach the next learning task, assessment, etc.
THAT's the point ....
Elem spec ed, 29th year (also gen ed, g/t, college experience) Indiana & Texas
I don't expect all of my students to 'earn' a diploma, but I also believe that some of them COULD earn a diploma if given more time and more support .. and if they were tested on material when they were READY to be tested on it.
You don't think that giving a kid until they're 22 is sufficient time to earn a diploma?
Not when phonics instruction has ended way back in second-third grade and the remedial focus then shifts to vocabulary and comp (for the rest of their school career). Dyslexic students may need continued phonics/phonemic awareness instruction all the way into high school and it doesn't exist in my district. So whether they stay until they're 22, they still can't read well because we haven't provided the appropriate instruction or support.
36 years in Public education. 9 years in self contained K-12 Hearing Impaired class; 4 years in self-contained K-5 SLI class (severe language impaired); 23 years SLP, the last 6 years in Middle and High schools.
Post by ladywclass on Sept 14, 2013 22:31:52 GMT -5
Sometimes I do ... (I'm in elementary grades K-6) and I have backing to write goals based on the students' needs and not on the grade level standards ...
Elem spec ed, 29th year (also gen ed, g/t, college experience) Indiana & Texas
Why not put phonemic awareness training into their IEP. That's specialized instruction.
In my district, our dyslexic kids are all in gen ed classes and have to follow the curriculum in those classes. Our district doesn't provide any phonics/PA materials for older kids. Most of our sped teachers spend their time "accommodating" the curriculum for the students and instructing the given materials in smaller groups in the classroom. I agree, we should be able to provide it, but apparently my district feels that "one size fits all" is the way to go. I think it's a money thing...we don't have the money to provide enough teachers for small group instruction (and our district mandates that 2/3 of the reading time must be delivered whole group) nor do we have the money to buy additional curriculum. IDEA funds which used to purchase such things are now being spent almost totally on salaries for specialists which the state used to pay for (behaviorists, speech/language pathologists, staffing specialists, PK diagnostic team, etc.). We've only had a very small # of parents challenge this...when they bring a lawyer, then my district somehow finds a way to meet that one child's needs.
36 years in Public education. 9 years in self contained K-12 Hearing Impaired class; 4 years in self-contained K-5 SLI class (severe language impaired); 23 years SLP, the last 6 years in Middle and High schools.
That's why admin is at IEP meetings. Admin's job is to 'allocate resources'. If admin, as part of the team, agrees to a plan, then it must be made clear to the entire team that resources are to go to implement the IEP as written.