This is for every teacher who refuses to be blamed for the failure of our society to erase poverty and inequality, and refuses to accept assessments, tests and evaluations imposed by those who have contempt for real teaching and learning.
Reading is great, joining is better - please sign in. For BATs, by BATs, we do not sell data!
BAT Store
Click image for link
We have now gotten a US Made and Union shop to sell us BAT shirts in all designs at a low cost.
Bumper stickers are coming soon and we hope to add more shirt types (tank, polo) if there is interest in the t-shirts!
Ncteacher, I am not connected with a school. I am retired now. I did teach, and I represented teachers on staff with Florida education association until retirement. I applaud and salute California. I did not represent transgendered teachers or support staff during my career. But I would have done so fiercely, with laws or without them. Ditto for students. That probably doesn't help you, but if you are testing the wind, that's where it blows personally for me.
Post by ladywclass on Aug 13, 2013 22:09:02 GMT -5
I thought I replied to this earlier but don't see my post! Wouldn't it be nice if 'public' restrooms - those intended to be shared by people outside of their own homes - were a little more private anyway? It would be easier for moms taking their little boys into the women's room - or men taking their daughters into a restroom with them! If they were more 'private', seems to me there wouldn't really be a 'transgender' issue with the restrooms ...
Elem spec ed, 29th year (also gen ed, g/t, college experience) Indiana & Texas
It concerns me because the CA ruling is so broad. I worry for the students who aren't transgendered. There are no requirements for these freedoms and knowing kids like I do I know there will be some peeping Toms taking advantage of the new law.
When the topic came up nationally last year I had male students who openly said they would lie just so they could sit and stare in the girls' locker rooms. Since CA doesn't require any 'proof' and all a boy has to say is "today I feel like a girl" it makes things too difficult to monitor.
Since boys have their business all put there when they pee it could make it uncomfortable for them as well when a girl walks in.
I can also see a slippery slope forming. What is to stop a second-rate male athlete from switching teams so he/she can break the girls' track record?
How far does this go? When does my straight non-transgender son get protection from feeling uncomfortable showering after gym? Do "female" yet male-bodied students get awarded athletic scholarships intended for girls? Does my college aged daughter have to room with a genetic male that identifies as female?
If there were some stipulations I would feel better about it. But right now it is too broad and dependent upon childish whims.
For the record I know only three transsexuals. All went from male to female. Two of them regretted their decisions within a year. One former student identified as male. I ran into her a few years later when she was a young adult. Wearing a dress and had long hair. She told me that once she got away from her screwed up family she began to understand who she really was and being a man was not part if that equation. So 3 out if the 4 people I knew who identified as the opposite gender didn't stick with it. My experience tells me this is not an exact science and until we can get some parameters in place we need not jeopardize the many in order to convenience the few.